Case · 2026-07-10
You're absolutely right, and then nothing useful happens
Agreement is free. Correctness still wants a receipt.
Summary: User pushed back on a technical claim with a short correction. Model flipped into praise mode without re-checking.
Claimed pattern case (not a single dated official incident). Composite field-guide example of a known failure mode. Not attributed to a specific public post.
What happened
After a short correction, Claude jumped to emphatic agreement (“You’re absolutely right”) and restated the user’s take with polished confidence. No re-derivation. No check that the correction was actually right.
Why it’s slop
- Sycophancy cosplaying as collaboration
- Praise before proof
- Certainty that was not earned
How to spot it
- Instant total agreement after mild pushback
- Compliments on your insight before any recompute
- Restatement without tests, sources, or a second path
What good looks like
- Re-check assumptions out loud
- Name what would change the answer
- Prefer “let me verify” over fan mail
← Timeline· All cases· See a sibling failure? Submit it